Best Peanut Chocolate Candy Taste Test

Today, we're having a spooky chocolate peanut candy showdown! GMM # 2051

Check out the Mythical Kitchen - www.youtube.com/mythicalkitchen
Listen to the MK Food Debate Podcast - www.mythical.com/hotdog

Subscribe to GMM: www.youtube.com/goodmythicalm...

Watch today's GMMORE: rofilm.info/much/video/gGXTlqZ1l6GlrnM
Click the bell icon so you'll know when we add a new episode!

Want more GMM? Check out these playlists:
Good Mythical Summer 2021 - www.youtube.com/playlist?list...
Season 19 - www.youtube.com/playlist?list...
Season 18 - www.youtube.com/playlist?list...
Season 17 - www.youtube.com/playlist?list...
Will It? - www.youtube.com/playlist?list...
Taste Tests! - www.youtube.com/playlist?list...

Get a copy of our novel, The Lost Causes of Bleak Creek @ www.bleakcreek.com

Pick up official GMM and Mythical merch at mythical.com
and www.amazon.com/mythical

Don’t miss our weekly podcast, Ear Biscuits: applepodcasts.com/earbiscuits

Join the Mythical Society: www.mythicalsociety.com

Follow Mythical:
Instagram: mythical
Facebook: mythical
Twitter: mythical
TikTok: tiktok.com/@mythical
Website: mythical.com

Check Out Our Other Mythical Channels:
Mythical Kitchen: youtube.com/mythicalkitchen
Rhett & Link: youtube.com/rhettandlink
Good Mythical MORE: youtube.com/goodmythicalmore

Want to send us something? mythical.com/contact

Submit your Wheel of Mythicality video here: bit.ly/GMMWheelIntroSUBMISSIONS

Intro Animation by Matthew Dwyer dwy.me and Mike Pasley DigitalTwigs.com
Intro & Outro Music by Mark Byers www.markaholic.com

In the spirit of minimizing food waste associated with the filming of this series, Mythical is donating to the Hollywood Food Coalition ( hofoco.org ) who provide daily, nourishing meals to underserved communities in the Los Angeles area.

Get the GMM Set Gear!
* Apple AirPort Extreme: amzn.to/2NnIvvk
* Apple iPad Pro (12.9-inch, Wi-Fi, 64GB) - Space Gray (Latest Model) - MTEL2LL/A: amzn.to/2NnKXlw
* Guardian Industrial Products DH-CP-4 3 Channel Rubber Cable Ramp (Straight): amzn.to/2NdshoR
* Cartoni Focus HD Fluid Head with 3 Tube Ultra-Light Tripod, Mid-Level Spreader and Soft Case - Black: amzn.to/2X4i7X8
* ARRI SkyPanel S60-C LED Softlight (Blue/Silver, Edison): amzn.to/2YgM3km
* Chef-Master 90050 Professional Heat Lamp, Silver: amzn.to/2Xa1Wwr
* Samsung UN40H5003 40-Inch 1080p LED TV (2014 Model): amzn.to/2NdMU4e
* Sony LMDA170 17" Production Video LCD Monitor, 16:9 Native Aspect Ratio, 1080p Resolution: amzn.to/2YlB9tH
* Behringer Xenyx 1002 Premium 10-Input 2-Bus Mixer with XENYX Mic Preamps and British Eqs: amzn.to/2Yeeqzl
* Elgato Game Capture Card HD60 S - Stream and Record in 1080p60, for PlayStation 4, Xbox One & Xbox 360 (Renewed): amzn.to/2NdOBP6
* Pyle Universal Speaker Stand Mount Holder - Heavy Duty Tripod w/ Adjustable Height from 40” to 71” and 35mm Compatible Insert - Easy Mobility Safety PIN and Knob Tension Locking for Stability PSTND2: amzn.to/2JcCpce
* JBL EON612 Portable 12" 2-Way Multipurpose Self-Powered Sound Reinforcement: amzn.to/2Ndluvm
* Bolt 500 XT 3G-SDI/HDMI Wireless TX/RX: amzn.to/2J1OeSk
* Voigtlaender 17,5/0,95 Nokton 17.5 mm-17.5 mm Lens: amzn.to/2JjUCEP
* Blackmagic Design Micro Converter SDI to HDMI (with Power Supply) BMD-CONVCMIC/SH/WPSU: amzn.to/2J6iw6y
* Panasonic H-HSA35100 F2.8 II ASPH 35-100mm Mirrorless Micro Four Thirds Mount POWER Optical I.S. LUMIX G X VARIO Professional Lens: amzn.to/2RAhIul
* PANASONIC LUMIX Professional 12-35mm Camera Lens G X VARIO II, F2.8 ASPH, Dual I.S. 2.0 with Power O.I.S., Mirrorless Micro Four Thirds, H-HSA12035 (2017 Model, Black): amzn.to/2J9WH5S
* Decimator Design DMON-12S | 12 Channel Multi Viewer with HDMI SDI Outputs: amzn.to/2J9Xkwg
* Decimator MD-HX HDMI and SDI Cross Converter with Scaling & Frame Rate Conversion: amzn.to/2Ymj52c
* PANASONIC LUMIX GH4 Body 4K Mirrorless Camera, 16 Megapixels, 3 Inch Touch LCD, DMC-GH4KBODY (USA Black): amzn.to/2WZjlD6
* Blue Microphones Mouse Microphone Kc: amzn.to/2Ybu12I

Comentarii: 2 245 

  1. Anne Foley

    Anne Foley

    Acum o Zi

    The miracle of the Peanut butter M&M is that it is NOT a Resses piece. Peanut butter is difficult to work with in candy making, so Reeses cups use a modified, sturdier concoction. It's not remotely the stuff you'd find in a jar or spread on a sandwich. Peanut Butter M&M's contain the same exact peanut butter you'd find in a jar.

    • Anne Foley

      Anne Foley

      Acum o Zi

      and can I just say- the seasonal Reeses have waxy, inferior chocolate.

  2. The Philosopher

    The Philosopher

    Acum 3 Zile

    The winner will forever be Reese’s peanut butter cups. It perfectly balances the peanut butter and chocolate.

  3. Laura Botting

    Laura Botting

    Acum 9 Zile

    Snickers used to be carried Marathon - at least they were here in the UK 🤔

  4. TwisTBlitzZ I

    TwisTBlitzZ I

    Acum 13 Zile

    Nah cap Reese’s cups are way better the seasonal ones have to much peanut butter

  5. Jilayne Miceli

    Jilayne Miceli

    Acum 14 Zile

    The shaped reeses are SO much better than the regular cups. More peanut better and a thinner smooth layer of chocolate. Sooooo good

  6. Raveman2002


    Acum 14 Zile

    Is anyone else so bothered by them using basically using Reece’s twice and having it win over butterfinger?

  7. Kerrie Savage

    Kerrie Savage

    Acum 14 Zile

    you all should do a Christmas candy challenge

  8. giraffe freaky

    giraffe freaky

    Acum 15 Zile

    I literal rodeo clown

  9. Lucas Harman

    Lucas Harman

    Acum 15 Zile

    Why is Reese's pieces not here? Better than ask these except Reese's pb cups

  10. Jesse Chavira

    Jesse Chavira

    Acum 16 Zile

    Link has a tattoo?

  11. Eliza T

    Eliza T

    Acum 18 Zile

    I feel like it’s universally understood that the reeses shapes are always better than the classic

  12. deloreanfan81


    Acum 21 o Zi

    I like her more as a food delivery person

  13. Kefalos


    Acum 22 Zile

    Not sure how Reese’s Pieces was not in this

  14. KTK


    Acum 22 Zile

    I don't know of anyone feels the same but I kind of really miss the songs they did. It was such enjoyable videos which I kind of miss. I wonder of they will ever create another one.

  15. Rman Nayr

    Rman Nayr

    Acum 22 Zile


  16. Rman Nayr

    Rman Nayr

    Acum 22 Zile

    THAT'S A LOT OF NUTS!!!!!!!!!!

  17. Nix


    Acum 23 Zile

    Peanut butter m&ms all day, every day! Link's tastebuds are obviously more refined than Rhett's...

  18. Ryan P

    Ryan P

    Acum 23 Zile

    The tie breaker was planned. At 10 minutes 1 second, tell me that isn’t rhett thinking “that wasn’t subtle”.

  19. Gagi Fri

    Gagi Fri

    Acum 23 Zile

    Tasting Reses peanut butter cup for the first time was such a disappointment, Being from Europe I expect some nice chocolate and filling to be neutral and complimentary to the chocolate, but omg was it discussing.

  20. M


    Acum 24 Zile

    I love pb

  21. shiaron


    Acum 24 Zile

    Snickers peanut butter is soo good

  22. Basement Banter

    Basement Banter

    Acum 25 Zile

    You guys don’t say “blamo!” Enough

  23. Courtney


    Acum 25 Zile


  24. KM Co

    KM Co

    Acum 26 Zile

    I was about to be so distraught if Reese’s did not win. You made the right choice.

  25. Makel


    Acum 26 Zile

    This was tilting to watch

  26. Me 1981

    Me 1981

    Acum 27 Zile

    Pressed Peanut Sweepings

  27. Adrestia


    Acum 27 Zile

    Can we talk about the fact that Links says he just learned trees have nuts?

  28. Kimberly Harris

    Kimberly Harris

    Acum 28 Zile

    Please do a doomsday food prep segment

  29. Rene Lopez

    Rene Lopez

    Acum 29 Zile

    I prefer Mr goodbar

  30. Don’t put a rifle in my hands

    Don’t put a rifle in my hands

    Acum 29 Zile


  31. Dave Del Lebo

    Dave Del Lebo

    Acum 29 Zile

    The Pumpkins, trees, eggs are way way Great!!!!!

  32. cami a

    cami a

    Acum lună

    I’ve hated butterfinger since they changed their recipe recently

  33. Crushenator500


    Acum lună

    Link's never seen the Simpsons? That's the saddest thing I've ever heard. Those early years were GOAT television.

    • ReallyNotThatFunny


      Acum lună


  34. ziggymeetstheworld


    Acum lună


  35. keara berthelot

    keara berthelot

    Acum lună

    This is where the candy went

  36. Pupperoni


    Acum lună

    This has prob already been said but they also make a pumpkin Snickers sooo I feel like this was unfair. XD Holiday Reese's still win every time though! They are so good!

  37. Sean Redeker

    Sean Redeker

    Acum lună

    I actually despise Reese’s peanut butter cups

  38. Candy Landy

    Candy Landy

    Acum lună

    This needed a Fastbreak!

  39. William Lemoine

    William Lemoine

    Acum lună

    Winnipeg Gang wya??????

  40. Brutal Coffee27

    Brutal Coffee27

    Acum lună

    Your telling me that all these years and I just now noticed link has a tattoo

  41. Marshall Ensley

    Marshall Ensley

    Acum lună

    Sending snickers to the finals because of nougat just taints the whole thing. This is about chocolate and peanut candies. Not nougat. Respect the integrity of the game guys.

  42. Anthony Peters

    Anthony Peters

    Acum lună

    Fail! No ZAGNUT Candy Bar or Chick-O-Stick !

  43. bob reno

    bob reno

    Acum lună

    microwaved pb m&ms are the best

  44. Carter Graham

    Carter Graham

    Acum lună

    He finally did it

  45. Sursie Metzger

    Sursie Metzger

    Acum lună

    I would honestly love to see some of the planning that goes into these holiday themed episodes. From the set to how they decide what to talk about. I think it would be pretty cool!

  46. Sandi J Smith

    Sandi J Smith

    Acum lună

    Nailed it!

  47. drycell183


    Acum lună

    Peanut butter Snickers are the best.

  48. Megan Covert

    Megan Covert

    Acum lună

    Hold the phone….when did link get a tattoo on the inside of his right arm?! Did I miss something?! How am I just discovering this?! Maybe I just have never noticed it? But we have seen them shirtless before!

  49. Katiegfff fcc

    Katiegfff fcc

    Acum lună

    Reese's needs its own category. Too many for this to be fair.

  50. ClaymanIFCC


    Acum lună

    There's a can of peanuts in my boots.

  51. Random


    Acum lună

    Pumpkin Reese’s > Original Reese’s

  52. Toknn


    Acum lună

    18:11 ‘Toumanent’ 🤣🤣

  53. Caleb Warden

    Caleb Warden

    Acum lună

    Emily is the best “not chase” John Wayne Chasey.

  54. Allison Holt

    Allison Holt

    Acum lună

    ***Episode idea*** Taste test special/holiday shaped candies against original. Example - Reese pumpkins tree vs eggs vs cups, Snickers nutcracker vs original. I happen to feel very passionately about how superior the snickers nutcracker is to the original!

  55. Blake Shoemaker

    Blake Shoemaker

    Acum lună

    The conversation at 16:38, followed by Emily’s deadpan delivery made this pharmacist laugh to the point of crying. Absolutely hilarious. 😂

  56. Megan Smith

    Megan Smith

    Acum lună

    Trying every Reeses product episode NEEDS to happen after this

  57. Wade Wilson

    Wade Wilson

    Acum lună

    How do these guys get dislikes? Seriously?

  58. Silver Ranger

    Silver Ranger

    Acum lună

    So, regardless, of WHO voted to include them, you managed to include Reese's PB chocolate TWICE !

  59. Ghost Crawler

    Ghost Crawler

    Acum lună

    I thought Kit-Kat Candy bar would be too 3 that was shocking to me

  60. Appaddict01


    Acum lună

    💯 agree on the pumpkin over the cups. The egg and Christmas trees, too. You get more peanut butter.🤤

  61. Owen Todd

    Owen Todd

    Acum lună

    Mr. Goodbar is so good though

  62. Taylor Hardiman

    Taylor Hardiman

    Acum lună

    i miss them trying to throw the candy into the buckett no look! bring back pzz

  63. Brian Evans

    Brian Evans

    Acum lună

    Did link get a bicep tat?

  64. My Topic’S & Opinion’S

    My Topic’S & Opinion’S

    Acum lună

    Well we know that the reese’s candy is going to win because they love peanut butter

  65. Caitlyn Knautz

    Caitlyn Knautz

    Acum lună

    I had NO clue Link had a tattoo on his arm!!!!

  66. Chase Calhoun

    Chase Calhoun

    Acum lună

    Peanut butter m&ms are way better

  67. Yikes McGikes

    Yikes McGikes

    Acum lună

    I wholeheartedly believe that seasonal and even some smaller “snack sized” candies are made differently to taste better than the regular full sized bars you get at the checkout or the gas station. That’s a theory I need tested. Blind taste test: full size, king size, fun size, snack size, holiday theme.. which tastes the best?!?

    • Hamile muneeb

      Hamile muneeb

      Acum 22 Zile

      thats what i think exactly

    • Andrew Almalhi

      Andrew Almalhi

      Acum 27 Zile

      That's a great episode idea

    • shook


      Acum 28 Zile

      @La Poubelle Also, I was gonna say, “king size always tastes better, then normal size, then fun/snack size”. Guess I just didn’t finish my sentence.

    • La Poubelle

      La Poubelle

      Acum 28 Zile

      @shook okay grammar 😑

    • shook


      Acum lună

      King size always tastes better, then normal size.

  68. Maggie


    Acum lună

    Apparently everyone is insane since the Pumpkins were rated lower than the regulars... WHAT ARE YOU GUYS ON

    • Maggie


      Acum lună

      Thank god they got this right

  69. Trinity Symone

    Trinity Symone

    Acum lună

    any Reeses shapes are superior. like the trees around Christmas time! its the peanut butter ratio

  70. utubemanize


    Acum lună

    I really like Mr goodbar :(

  71. V11V


    Acum lună

    just saying if i did this everything we be so diffrent

  72. Tiffany Newcomb

    Tiffany Newcomb

    Acum lună

    They should have a peanut butter and jelly Reese´s

  73. Uncle Monkey

    Uncle Monkey

    Acum lună

    I wonder if other staff members did this if it would be the same results?

  74. Grunge Head

    Grunge Head

    Acum lună

    Haha that's how Angry Video Game Nerd says tournament.

  75. Georgia Wildflower

    Georgia Wildflower

    Acum lună

    I just adore Emily. She is one of my favorite GMM crew members. 😘

  76. eastportland


    Acum lună

    Reese's Crunchy Peanut Butter Cups were my favorite: a traditional cup with crunchy peanut butter, as opposed to the smooth peanut butter in the original. Introduced in the 1970s. It has been discontinued and rereleased over the years. Still available in some markets as of 2019.

  77. J Uhl

    J Uhl

    Acum lună

    Great video as always but I can’t help but wonder if the big cup pb cup should have been evaluated against the pumpkin pb cup.

  78. Robert Frye

    Robert Frye

    Acum lună


  79. Mike's Vegas

    Mike's Vegas

    Acum lună

    I’m surprised there’s no Reese's Pieces 🤔

  80. FienX


    Acum lună

    i speak collectively for the community when i say we demand 1440p video quality.

  81. Alex Valles

    Alex Valles

    Acum lună


  82. Quintino Zaccardelli

    Quintino Zaccardelli

    Acum lună

    Gimme a break, a Kit Kat break

  83. ThisisFizban


    Acum lună

    I'm not a huge fan of Snickers but I just tried the peanut butter Snickers and it was a revelation.

  84. Jaime Knoble

    Jaime Knoble

    Acum lună

    Man, Mr. Goodbar is my favorite of the choices here. I'm sad.

  85. Isha Khan

    Isha Khan

    Acum lună


  86. joshua nieves

    joshua nieves

    Acum lună

    i agree, peanut m&m's are better

  87. Jr Avila

    Jr Avila

    Acum lună

    The Easter egg Reese’s is the best, no debate

  88. Nick H

    Nick H

    Acum lună

    Those Reese’s peanut butter pumpkins have to be super unhealthy but it’s in a tier of it’s own when it comes to taste.

  89. Coupons Discount

    Coupons Discount

    Acum lună

    Feel like these 3 could have been one video about candy

  90. Vincenzo Diorio

    Vincenzo Diorio

    Acum lună

    Who would have thought the winner was a reeses

  91. mojo782


    Acum lună

    How has Link never seen an episode of the Simpsons? It's been on for like 30 years!

  92. Mike Mack

    Mike Mack

    Acum lună

    Putting M&Ms against each other but not the two Reese's products against each other is unfair.

  93. Alex Townley

    Alex Townley

    Acum lună

    Peanut Butter M&M’s are way better imho.

  94. heather marien

    heather marien

    Acum lună

    reeses pieces deserve better man

  95. Shane Montgomery

    Shane Montgomery

    Acum lună

    I love the Recees Pumpkins - but you have to freeze them! Soooo goood!!!!

  96. Adam Autumn

    Adam Autumn

    Acum lună

    I do not enjoy either of the two last candies. Bring on the fruit candy.

  97. Ren Will

    Ren Will

    Acum lună

    Hmm what about payday

  98. Taylor Nicole

    Taylor Nicole

    Acum lună

    Emily is my favorite part of good mythical morning 😂

  99. SqueekySea


    Acum lună

    Am I the only one mad that peanut butter MnMs lost?